Suicide Series Part 1: Trinity County Tops the State in Suicides; Shasta County Doubles State Suicide Average

Editor’s Note: This is the first in a four-part series by reporter Bill Siemer that examines suicide statistics and what people are doing to help.

Shasta County residents commit suicide at twice the statewide average. Trinity County ranks the highest of all the counties in the state for suicide. White men over the age of 84 commit suicide more than others. Suicide rates among American Indians nationally are higher than those of other Americans. No one knows how many military veterans are killing themselves, but the estimate is one every 80 minutes. Active-duty soldiers are taking their own lives at a higher rate than ever before.

No one fully understands this complex problem. “Hopelessness” seems to be the answer most often given. People are trying to do something about it. The voters passed Proposition 63 in 2004, taxing millionaires to help fund county mental health programs. Phone crisis lines are available to help. But people who have bottomed out, who see suicide as their only option, don’t ask for help.

Sobering statistics

Trinity County has the dubious distinction of having the highest suicide rate in California, according to a July 11 story in The Trinity Journal. Nationally, there are 10 suicides a year for every 100,000 people. Trinity County, which has a population of less than 14,000, has an average of seven suicides a year, five times the national rate.

Local officials blame the high rate of suicide on isolation, substance abuse and the number of firearms. They are taking steps to reduce suicide by installing a “friendship” line for senior citizens and another for young people with text and chat options. Both will be staffed by volunteers.

In 2011 there were 54 suicides in Shasta County, according to Janet Breshears, chief deputy coroner for the past two years and a member of the Sheriff’s Office for 25 years. Of these, 33 were gunshot deaths; there were also 11 hangings, six overdoses, two deaths by carbon monoxide, and two by blunt force trauma. Overdoses are the most difficult to determine. The scene of the death is important. Is there a note? Are there empty pill containers? Have there been prior attempts? Pistols are used in most gunshot deaths, though it’s not uncommon to have long guns involved.

The coroner’s office determines what is suicide and what isn’t. If there is any doubt, they lean toward finding that the cause of death is “undetermined,” Breshears said.  That’s because of the stigma attached to suicide or attempted suicide, which keeps people from talking about it or taking steps to prevent it.

There are 192,000 people in Shasta County, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Katie Cassidy and Jeremy Wilson of Shasta County Mental Health compiled suicide statistics for Shasta County between the years of 2007 and 2009. Shasta County, and most rural counties, have a higher rate of suicide than urban areas. Basically, twice as many people kill themselves in Shasta County compared with the state rate.

Their Shasta County Suicide Prevention Community Assessment found that middle-aged, white males are most likely to commit suicide, except for men 84 years and older, who take their lives more than any other group. In Shasta County, males have a much higher rate of suicide death than females because they are more likely to use firearms. Females, however, have a higher rate of suicide attempts.

Suicide in American Indian population

Neither the community assessment nor the coroner’s office keeps track of the ethnicity of suicides. However, the Indian Health Service, in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, estimates in a recent report that American Indians have an 82 percent higher suicide rate than other Americans.

Suicide is the second leading cause of death for young Indian males between the ages of 10 and 24. The suicide rate for Indian males in 2003, according to another study, was two to four times that of same-age males in other racial or ethnic groups and eleven times that of same-age females.

Dennis Thompson, a drug and alcohol counselor for the Pit River Health Service in Burney, and Melinda Adams, the behavioral health director at the same facility, said that the rate of American Indian suicides is significantly under-reported.

“People wander off…bodies are found,” they said. The American Indian population doesn’t talk about it or seek help. There is stigma attached to suicide, just as there is in the Caucasian culture. Why does suicide have such a stigma? Adams theorizes it’s because we are so afraid of our own deaths that we are threatened by the subject.

Adams is one of the facilitators of the Women’s Talking Circle. That meeting offers safety, she says, and members talk about everything, including death and suicide. All 10 members are over 55. It has been in existence for two-and-a-half years, meeting weekly. It gives her hope that the suicide issue in the American Indian population will someday be addressed.

Thompson and Adams are responsible for American Indians from Burney to Alturas, 1,300 in total. There is “intergenerational” post-traumatic stress and substance abuse in that community.

“Anyone who has worked with the Native Americans has knowledge of the broken promises and treaties, Indian boarding schools, relocation to rural reservations, the prejudice and oppression,” Thompson says.

Only 33 percent of American Indians graduate from high school—which contributes to 37 percent unemployment and little trust for white Americans and the institutions they provide. American Indians rarely use any of the local drug and alcohol programs. And, unfortunately, Thompson and Adams have nowhere to send their suicidal clients, often being forced to send them home to troubled families and alcohol and drugs.

Suicide rate among senior citizens

The highest rate of suicides in Shasta County is men 84 years old and over, according to the Shasta County Suicide Prevention Community Assessment. Between 2007 and 2009, about 55 out of every 100,000 in that age group killed themselves. The next highest group was men between the ages of 35 and 44, who committed suicide at a rate of approximately 35 out of every 100,000.

“Older people are far less ambivalent about suicide than young people,” said  Patrick Arbore, a representative of The Friendship Line out of San Francisco. Arbore spoke to the task force from several northern counties at the Superior Region of the Suicide Prevention Network in Redding in June.

“It is so hard to get people to understand that aging and depression are not synonymous,” he said. “Older people become very lonely and isolated. They do not understand that they have depression, that it can be mitigated, remediated.”

It is important to let them know they are still part of the community, he said.

The Friendship Line, which operates on a budget of $5,000 a year, and bills itself as “a caring response to older adults in need,” is part of the Center for Elderly Suicide Prevention, a San Francisco-based program that provides support to at-risk seniors, family members and their advocates, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

It is more than just a phone line and a warm, understanding voice. It also provides medication reminders, well-being checks and information and referrals. The number is 1-1-800-971-0016.

Arbore is willing to make presentations to groups of elderly people, including at senior housing facilities.

Bill Siemer grew up on a farm in Lassen County, played basketball at Shasta JC, went to Vietnam, became a newspaper reporter and then a lawyer and now considers himself a champion of the story that needs to be told. He lives on the bank of the river and takes pictures.

Bill Siemer
Bill Siemer grew up on a farm in Lassen County, played basketball at Shasta JC, went to Vietnam, became a newspaper reporter and then a lawyer and now considers himself a champion of the story that needs to be told. He lives on the bank of the river and takes pictures.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

11 Responses

  1. Avatar Sherri Batie says:

    Nice article! Statistics seem to include known suicides. Many classified unknown or accident may be suicides. The numbers could actually be much higher. I worked at Helpline for many years and saw first hand that many that were known to us as suicidal where later deemed accidents. It is a tough reporting standard to ease the burden of families dealing with a death of a loved one.

  2. Avatar ReddingBob says:

    There is also a correlation between MJ use and suicide. MJ is not medicine for everyone who wants it, for sure.

  3. "Isolation, substance abuse, and the number of firearms." Grave conditions. Does our county have even barely adequate support services?

    A powerful and heart-rending article Mr. Siemer.

  4. Avatar Kathryn says:

    Thanks for bringing attention to this very important issue! The number of Survivors of Suicide is high here, too — the number of people whose lives have been devastated by the suicide of someone close to them. I am glad you wrote about this.

  5. Avatar Canda says:

    I look forward to your series, Bill. I think most of us have been affected by friends and family members who have taken their own lives. It would be wonderful to have more information on how we can help those who are despondent.

  6. Avatar Sharon says:

    Powerful article, Bill. It is sobering to look at the rates of suicide in our county in comparison with state rates; we have a higher percentage of suicides that involve guns, no? Thank you so much for this series.

  7. Avatar Joanne Lobeski Snyde says:

    Thank you for an excellent article Bill. These are very disturbing statistics. I really believe that when people experience the kind of depression and hopelessness that could lead to suicide, they have no knowledge or frame of reference for that depth of despair. I look forward for your next articles.

  8. James Montgomery James Montgomery says:

    The reported rates do not even include what is probably the #1 form of suicide: automobiles. Just drive off a cliff, or into a tree at high speed. It is the perfect method; no one can ever be sure it was suicide, especially if you have the foresight to drink a pint of whiskey first. Insurance companies will still pay, and family members will not blame themselves.

    The perfect time to kill yourself? Tomorrow. Have a little fun, today. Take a walk by the river. Read a book. Call your children. Go fishing. Visit an old friend. Go to a movie. Since you are going to die tomorrow, anyway, you are free today. Do something you enjoy.

  9. Avatar Joanne Lobeski Snyde says:

    James response brought to my mind older male friends of mine who have decided, ahead of time that they would take things into their own hand if they were faced with months or years of pain, helplessness or uselessness. I talked earlier about depression and hopelessness, but the people I'm referencing now are not depressed nor feel hopeless. They have made a rational decision.

  10. Avatar bill siemer says:

    Joanne – People making rational decisions to take their own lives is something people in the suicide prevention business really do not want to talk about. I'm glad you brought it up. Also, Jim's comment about drinking a pint of whiskey and driving into a tree was referenced in my original article, referrring to American Indians. That part was edited out. bill

  11. Avatar Dan says:

    Excellent read. A childhood friend I lost contact with commited suicide. Since then I have made a point of keeping in touch with friends going through trama. It only takes a minute to send a card, pick-up the phone or share on Facebook.

    I had a long conversation with a Japanese friend on this subject. He said Westerners have a warped view of suicide. "We all die..suicide simply allows a man to choose the time and place of death if necessary..and places him above the animals". In the case of an 84 year old facing a horrific painful passing perhaps. I suppose that is not my place to judge, but it is sad if anyone feels suicide is the only option.