Mistress of the Mix: Letter To My Former Flirtation

Editor's note: If you appreciate posts like this and want ANC to continue publishing similar content, become a paid subscriber for as little as $1.35 a month.

About a decade ago, I thought I was ready to learn how to date the opposite sex. I was newly single after a pretty miserable marriage between two mismatched people. The only thing we really had in common anymore was our love for our daughter, and that really shouldn’t have been enough to keep us together. But we kept plodding along at it, and by the time we finally went our separate ways, we had been together for 18 years. And I’m not proud of that fact. Because we should’ve given up long before then.

I bring it up because I want you to understand how inexperienced I was at dating. As a teenager, I almost never dated, because every first date turned into a long relationship. I met a guy when I was 15 that I dated until I was in my first year of college. At 18 I met a man that I was with until I turned 21. At 22, I met the man I married.

So there I was, freshly single, and 41 years old, finally ready to date. I wasn’t really looking for another husband, I just wanted to have fun. I’m a fun girl, right? So I thought it was going to be relatively easy.

I was so naïve. But then again, I hadn’t had a first date since 1989. Everything had changed since then. I just didn’t realize how much. As it turned out, dating after 40 turned out to be one of the most ridiculously frustrating experiences of my adult life. Especially because I tried that newfangled dating trend that hadn’t been around the last time I was in the game. Internet dating. It’s not for the faint of heart, especially for those of us who remember a time before there was a thing called the internet.

I actually paid good money to an online dating site in the Spring of 2008 to get my profile out there on the world wide web for three whole months in hopes of getting connected with potential dates. In my profile, I described myself as a voluptuous fireball, a music lover and expert Boggle player who was looking for a man with a wicked sense of humor who wasn’t intimidated by confidence.  What I ended up with were a bunch of hilarious and semi-humiliating stories, my dating pratfalls. I racked up so many pathetically funny stories of my lame dating encounters that I started detailing them in a blog, Kiss And Tell The World.

I’ve locked that blog down now, but every once in awhile – usually when one of my girlfriends over the age of 40 finds herself back out on the dating circuit – I’ll open it back up to share with her just so she’ll be a little bit more prepared for the surprises ahead. Surprises like the time I realized the fella I’d been on a few dates with wasn’t a divorced father of two, he was the very married father of two kids who were out of town for a few weeks with their mom.

It only took a few months for me to decide to shut down my online dating profile, and I’ll tell you why. It was when I realized that a pattern was emerging. It was a pattern so obvious that I even tested it in a sort-of scientific experiment of sorts. Not just once, but twice. And after the second time, I cancelled my account and vowed to never ever do the one thing ever again that guaranteed I wouldn’t get a second date, and most likely meant I wouldn’t even achieve the goal of a first date.

That thing? That one thing, the common denominator that was putting a hex on all my potential first dates? Instead of just telling you, I’ll share with you a letter I wrote to my last potential first date. A man that I had been carrying on a pretty decent internet flirtation with for several weeks, until I did the thing. That thing I had already tested and proven that I shouldn’t have done if I wanted a date.

Dear Former Flirtation from Fairfield,

I know we had a date set for tonight, and I know you’re not going to show. You haven’t told me, I just know these things. But before I set my backup plan in motion and settle in for a Battlestar Galactica marathon, I wanted to share with you the story of my phone number jinx. Maybe I should call it a curse. You see, every time I give my phone number to a man, it pretty much guarantees that he will fall off the face of the earth.

I know, sounds stupid. But hear me out. It’s actually sort of a fascinating sad tale of my recent dating disasters. I was gonna wait to tell you. But, well, you’ll see why I’m telling you now.

Months ago, I had a date with a guy. It went well. Really well, I thought. At the end of the evening he asked me what I wanted. He wasn’t really clear what he was talking about, but I said, “I want you to call me.” He said he definitely would. So I gave him my phone number. 

He most definitely never did.

Oh well. Moving on.

The next man I gave my number to was the first person I ‘met’ online. Local guy. We talked back and forth for a few days, he wanted to meet me right away. So I gave him my phone number. Never heard from him again. I even wrote to him about a week later wondering what happened to him, because he seemed so eager. He didn’t even bother responding with a polite rejection.

I was perplexed, I had questions unanswered. But I kept moving on.

The 3rd man was a nurse who worked at a children’s hospital in Sacramento. We had been corresponding for a while, when we finally decided we wanted to meet. We had a great connection. He wanted to drive up here, so we made a date. For the following Sunday.

So I gave him my phone number so we could at least speak to each other before the date. That very night he went out with some co-workers. The story he gave me was that he started gushing about me and our connection to one of his friends. One of his female friends. By the end of the night, he was smitten with her, and decided to break off our date and all communication so he could focus on her.

Moving right along.

It was then that I became convinced that I had some kind of phone number hex. So I did an experiment. I accepted a date with a guy who had been hounding me for a date while I was interested in the nurse. I had politely declined (telling him the truth, that I had a connection with someone else at the moment, but thanks). But truthfully, I had absolutely no interest in the other man whether or not I had a connection with someone else. To test the hex, I emailed the man and told him I’d have dinner with him the next evening if he was free. He was. I told him to meet me in front of the Cascade Theatre, and just in case, gave him my phone number. Then I just sat back and waited to see how long it would take him to break the date, or prove my theory wrong.

Twelve hours. 

Twelve hours later, I had an email breaking off our date due to a family emergency. I was pretty relieved this time, because I honestly didn’t want to meet this guy. I was just proving my theory.

From then, I have made a steadfast rule of not giving my number to men that I’m interested in. Except for you. So I take full responsibility for whatever it is that caused you to drop off the face of the earth.

  • If your plane went down somewhere over New Mexico, it’s my fault.
  • If you were rushed to the hospital for emergency knee surgery and then came down with a nasty staph infection that they can’t seem to get a handle on so you’re stuck in an electric bed eating jello without access to your email? It’s me, not you. Sorry ’bout that.
  • If you have suddenly become madly infatuated with another woman, you’d better invite me to the wedding, because I’m the female version of “Good Luck Chuck.” 
  • If you’ve decided to try to make a go of it one more time with your ex, you’ve got me to thank. (Yes, that’s happened to me too….but that’s another story.)
  • And I hope this hasn’t happened, but if your best friend’s dad dropped dead suddenly and you had to head into a cell free zone for the funeral, blame me. Cause that was what caused my last date to disappear. So sad.

So I apologize for giving you my phone number. Because I really enjoyed talking with you and was looking forward to meeting you. I was pretty convinced that we would really like each other in person and that we’d have a great time together. I looked forward to receiving your emails, which were so funny and smart, and I was having a really good time writing to you. It was just a dumb, weak moment when I convinced myself that the whole phone number jinx wasn’t real, but I now recognize, respect and surrender to the power of the curse that has made it virtually impossible for me to successfully get a date. 

So don’t feel bad that you went into radio silence right before our date. It’s really not your fault, no matter what happened.

I never sent that letter, but I also never heard from the Former Flirtation from Fairfield ever again.

If you’re wondering if there’s a happy ending to this story, there actually is, and if memory serves, it happened about a week later. That was when my parents told me that my former junior high school boyfriend had looked their number up in the phone book, and had called looking for me. My mother (who must have known all about the jinx), refused to give him my number. Instead, she told him that she’d be happy to give his number to me, and that I could call if I was so inclined.

I waited about a week, and then I called him (from my work phone), and it took him all of five minutes to ask me if he could drive down from Oregon to visit me that weekend. I told him to meet me Saturday at 5 in front of the Cascade Theatre.But I didn’t give him my phone number. Because, you know, the jinx.So yeah, of course he showed up. And of course I married him.

Perhaps you’ve got tales of dating pratfalls of your own to share. In fact I don’t think I’ve met a person over 40 that’s re-entered the dating scene that doesn’t have a story or two (or twelve). So go ahead, here’s your safe space. Let it all out. And while you’re at it, check out the streaming playlist below, the Internet Dating Lament. It’s not easy to find good songs about internet dating. But it’s really easy to find absolutely horrible, awful songs about internet dating. So I’ve collected a whole bunch of them just for you (aren’t I sweet?) and they’re all right here. But today’s playlist comes with a bonus. I’ve found that besides really bad music, internet dating has also spawned some pretty funny comedy routines on the subject, and you’ll find some of those intertwined with the music. Now that I think about it, mixing in comedy makes for a perfect playlist on this subject matter, because that’s pretty much what I was left with after my foray into internet dating…a couple of funny stories.

Valerie Ing
Valerie Ing has been the Northern California Program Coordinator for Jefferson Public Radio in Redding for 14 years and can often be found serving as Mistress of Ceremonies at the Cascade Theatre. For her, ultimate satisfaction comes from a perfect segue. She and her husband are parents to a couple of college students and a pair of West Highland Terriers, and Valerie can’t imagine life without them or music. The Mistress of the Mix wakes up every day with a song in her head, she sings in the shower and at the top of her lungs in the car.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

24 Responses

  1. Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

    Almost sixty years ago we had our own online dating in Salt Lake City. It was called Moondial. We would call some where that we were guaranteed a busy signal, I would call the weather station. Than between the beep-beep-beep we would holler our phone numbers. Usually it was guys that did the hollering, the girls didn’t holler their numbers much, probably because of the reasons you listed. Rather quickly I would get a call from a girl and we would talk, feeling each other out for BS. I did get dates out of it and some were frequent dates. I met my first wife that way and it lasted six years. Moondial was much more successful and cheaper than our version of American Graffiti, dragging Main Street. Dating has changed and I’m glad I haven’t had to for forty years. I credit that for marrying, second marriage, a Hayfork girl even though I met her in San Francisco at a “Meat Market” bar.

  2. Valerie Ing Valerie Ing says:

    What a wild story, Bruce! I had no idea that back in the day you would be connected with other callers on a busy signal!!! That’s whacky!

    • Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

      Val I guess this would be my song. Jenny 867-5309.

      • Mistress of the Mix Mistress of the Mix says:

        When I was a kid growing up in Eugene, 867 was an actual telephone prefix there, although I’d just moved away when Tommy Tutone released that song. I wonder how many of my friends from junior high called it!

  3. Avatar Richard says:

    Brilliant writing. Thanks for heightening the appreciation of a long and satisfying marriage.

  4. Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

    Your story mirrors that of Doni sometime back when she described some of her online dates. The one that sticks in my mind is the 5’4″ guy who described himself a 6′ tall in his profile. If ya gotta lie about your height, what else are ya hiding?

    Fun read, Mistress. Thanks.

  5. Barbara Rice Barbara Rice says:

    Oh yes. I did the internet thing too.

    The guy who met me at Barnes & Noble for coffee and brought his own bottle of water so he wouldn’t have to spend any money, then talked for one hour nonstop about his custom-built home.

    The guy I got along with superbly online. When we met for lunch, he apparently hated me on sight and was surly and irritable, then groused, “I supposed you expect me to pay for lunch.” At that point I felt enduring an hour of his company entitled me to a free lunch.

    The local elected official who was in an “open marriage.” He was difficult to dissuade.

    The MANY guys who obviously didn’t read my profile or they would have known there wasn’t a snowball’s chance in hell of us getting along.

    The numerous requests for friends with benefits.

    But I also met my husband, so it worked out after all.

    • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

      I guess you separated the wheat from the chaff – or in your case, the Rice from the hulls.

  6. Terry Turner Terry Turner says:

    You told this story so well, Valerie. I, too, have heard so many stories of internet dating that it keeps me far away. 🙂

  7. Avatar Karen Calanchini says:

    Great story Valerie, you have had some very interesting life experiences. My life seems so boring compared!

    I did not date a lot in high school, preferring to spend my time at the skating rink, lessons, competitions, local performances, etc. I also preferred older guys, as the ones my age seemed so immature. My one interesting boyfriend in high school was homeless and I never knew it until I found out he ended up being a professor at Brigham Young University and wrote a book about his homelessness. He is a well known family and marriage counselor, and has a few books out there on finance also. Amazing, that he and his family could have been homeless for so many years and I did not have a clue. He was well groomed, clean and very well spoken. He kept the secret very well.

  8. Deb Segelitz Deb Segelitz says:

    Great article!! I wouldn’t have the courage for online dating; then again, I wasn’t much of a date-goer of any kind at any point anyway… not that they were beating a path to my door! Oddly enough, though, my first long-term relationship (7 years) started in a random AOL chat room (remember those?) and my longest relationship, the marriage I am in today (11 years and counting!), sparked to life on a blog site, against all kinds of odds. So while I didn’t internet-date, I suppose you could say I have internet-relationshipped. 🙂 Thank you for the entertaining read!

  9. Adrienne Jacoby Adrienne Jacoby says:

    I’m so old any on-line dating referred to exchanging phone numbers on an abacus! . . . . but even given the vagrancies of “old time style dating” (what-the-heck ever THAT means) there was a point in my life when I managed to fall hard and fast and frequently!! With or without the help of the internet and social media, the vagrancies of human interaction all seem to stay about the same.
    Couldn’t help but think of ‘Taking a Chance on Love.’

  10. Avatar Carla says:

    I have the same problem. Two dates, 2 marriages over 46 years or so. I guess I don’t get the whole concept of dating.

  11. So funny, Val! You made my Friday.

    (And I remember your blog. Seems like so long ago.)

  12. Avatar Claudia Hastings says:

    I so enjoy reading your posts! Keep them coming!

  13. Joanne Snyder Joanne Snyder says:

    This is such a great discussion! I wasn’t allowed to date or have friends over to the house when I was growing up. I was so completely ignorant when I went on a couple of dates in college….and they were horrible. “Why would we get in the back seat to see the movie? I can see it from here.” I learned so much more about people by being in a working situation: a big party to work on a new “fixer upper” home…glazing new windows, painting walls and then breaking bread together.
    A trick an ex-wife of a boyfriend of mine did was brilliant. She went out on the town…all the bars on Hilltop and gave my phone number as her phone number. I would get a call from a man who would be annoyed that I didn’t remember him. “I” had given him my number after all. So awkward.

    • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

      Joanne, since you weren’t allowed to date or have friends over to your house, did you go to public school or were you perhaps home schooled? Did you feel the need to get away from home as soon as you were old enough? Yours sounds like a very sheltered childhood.

      • Joanne Snyder Joanne Snyder says:

        Beverly, I went to public shools. I was very sheltered except for the fact that there were lots of books in the house. I read Gone with the Wind and War and Peace by the time I was in the 8th grade. I’ve read both a couple of times since and so, in a sense I wasn’t as sheltered as one might think. Two siblings left before the age of 18. I went on my way after I graduated from high school…so very unprepared. It’s a long story. Thanks for asking Beverly. I think of you everytime I prepare food!

        • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

          Nice to be thought of in the kitchen! Let’s get together for coffee or tea or, better yet, wine!

  14. Joanne Snyder Joanne Snyder says:

    I know people who have enjoyed lasting relationships with people they met online. Getting to know people by writing instead of talking is powerful. If I were going to do this one day, one lie about anything would be a deal breaker.

    • Valerie Ing Valerie Ing says:

      That was definitely part of the problem, Joanne. So many lies right out of the gate. Why try to start a relationship with deception? That’s a recipe for disaster.

  15. Avatar Richard Christoph says:

    Of the 22 comments above, 19 are from females and only 3 are from males. I have had no experience in online dating but would enjoy reading an ANC story from a guy who has. Anyone?

    • Hal Johnson Hal Johnson says:

      No internet dating for me, but in the late 80s, I once responded to a personal ad in the Ventura Star-Free Press. We had I nice dinner date. She was interesting, well-traveled, and well-read. I felt no chemistry whatsoever. I’m pretty sure she also felt no chemistry whatsoever. That was that.