A Film Review: ‘A Star is Born’

When I became aware of the impending release of Bradley Cooper’s rendition of “A Star is Born” a few weeks ago, I decided to use the occasion to screen the three previous versions of the classic Hollywood tale. The first two films (starring Janet Gaynor and Judy Garland) graced the screen many years before I was born, and I missed the 1976 Barbra Streisand/Kris Kristofferson vehicle out of simple teenage indifference.

I thought it might be fun, perhaps even instructive in a generational mores sort of way, to set aside a day to binge-watch the first three movies and then compare and contrast each film’s interpretation of the now-familiar story of an established-but-fading performer discovering and falling in love with a young, unknown talent, and their subsequent nurturing the young performer to stardom while the seasoned performer’s own star fades due to drugs, alcohol and insecurity. Unfortunately,  technical difficulties prevented me from having the “A Star is Born” marathon, so I attended the screening of the newest incarnation completely cold – without benefit of a trailer – and only the sketchiest knowledge of the storyline. In the end, none of this mattered.

“A Star is Born”– as produced, co-written, and directed by Bradley Cooper (the key grip job was already taken) is a breathtaking revelation. Virtually every aspect of this highly entertaining film brims with surprise and wonder – and a genuine love of music and that place in our souls from whence it comes. Filmmaking – the actual physical, psychological, creative and collaborative efforts required to make a film — is an extraordinarily difficult art to render well. It’s hard work even to make a bad film – even one with the best of intentions.

Bradley Cooper, the actor, has demonstrated his growth and maturity in front of the camera in a number of recent Oscar-nominated performances (“Silver Linings Playbook”, “American Hustle”, “American Sniper”), so it’s in keeping with that trend that his performance here as Jackson Maine, a boozing, pill-popping country-rock star at the pinnacle of his career would be among his finest to date. Cooper disappears into Jackson Maine – voice and all – as completely as the character of Jackson Maine disappears into the embodiment of his half-brother and long-suffering manager, played by Sam Elliott in what might be his best work.

It’s Bradley’s Cooper’s work here behind the camera as producer and director that is most impressive. In addition to writing several of the film’s songs, he has coaxed magnificent performances out of the entire cast, which includes Stefani Germanotta (known professionally as Lady Gaga), Dave Chappelle, Andrew Dice Clay, Ron Rifkin, and the aforementioned Sam Elliott. Everyone here is on top of their game; including Cooper himself.

In the film’s opening sequence, he chooses to present most of the concert footage from his character’s on-stage perspective, giving us an objective view of his performing world and his continuing on-stage battle with his addictions and tinnitus. We don’t see what the audience sees (and hears). What we get is this performer’s aural and visual perspective, and it is at once thrilling and frightening.

One night after a show in Los Angeles, Jackson Maine (Bradley Cooper) goes off in search of a drink. He disappears into the first bar his driver can find, a drag bar where he meets Ally, a nightclub singer (Lady Gaga). He is mesmerized by her obvious talent, and he insists she join him for an evening of music, bar-hopping, wound-dressing, and self-discovery. It isn’t long before the grizzled rock star has fallen in love with Ally. He takes her on the road, and gives her the opportunity to share her songs and her voice with his audience. In time, they marry, and Ally’s star begins its ascent while Jackson falls deeper into his addictions.

Much has been made of Gaga’s screen debut. She demonstrates she isn’t a singer moonlighting as an actor. She is an actor. Period. (My movie companion, unaware of Gaga’s involvement in the film, leaned over to me in the dark and whispered: “Who is that? She’s great!” Her delight upon seeing Lady Gaga’s name during the credit roll was one of the film’s great pleasures for this reviewer.) Cooper also impresses as the singer-songwriter, Jackson Maine. His band is played by Lukas Nelson and The Promise of the Real. In interviews, Cooper has joked that the songwriting process continued throughout the shooting of the film, and that while he originally envisioned Jackson Maine as a country musician, the sound of the songs and the band migrated toward a more rock and roll approach, and if they had continued writing and shooting much longer, they might have ended up as a heavy metal band.

Ultimately, the success of this film, artistically and commercially, rests with the quality of the love story. Do our lead actors have true onscreen chemistry? Fortunately, Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga have it in spades. Emotionally, nothing is forced between their characters. The relationship is allowed to develop organically. We fall in love with Jackson and Ally as they fall in love with each other.

At one point in the film, Jackson Maine questions his creative protégé about whether she still has something to say, artistically speaking. An audience will know when you’re lying to them. If you want to stick around for a long time, you must tell them the truth. In his version of “A Star is Born”, Bradley Cooper has proved he has something to say. He’ll be around for a while.

Michael Jewel Haley
Michael Jewel Haley is a Bay Area artist, photographer and writer.  He grew up in Redding, and developed his love of movies during Saturday matinees at the Cascade Theater. See samples of his artwork here.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

19 Responses

  1. Avatar Judy says:

    One of the finest productions in a long time. The music and story haunt us. No matter what the Academy does, it will be a long while before this level of talent is assembled and displayed in a compelling recital.

    • Michael Jewel Haley Michael Jewel Haley says:

      I couldn’t agree more, Judy. The entertainment industry has undergone major changes in the past 20 years, and it’s become extremely rare to see such a staggering collection of talent in a single feature film. Fortunately for those of us who still enjoy the experience of sitting in a darkened movie palace with our Honey and a tub of popcorn, Bradley Cooper is a passionate film lover with old school movie sensibilities. I hope we see more of these grownup screen gems from him.

  2. Avatar Judy says:

    Randall R. Smith

  3. Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

    This remake has been in the Arizona news. Apparently, because of movie tax credits, the shots of Arizona were actually done in California, Coachella to be exact.

    • Michael Jewel Haley Michael Jewel Haley says:

      Funny to think it’s more economically feasible to shoot in California, but not hard to imagine the Coachella Valley as a serviceable stand-in for Arizona.

      • Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

        Many states have gotten movies because of favorable tax credits. Wyoming is one of the favorable business tax states but apparently not for movies. That is why Longmire was filmed in New Mexico.
        I often wonder why Shasta and neighboring counties don’t get more film making. The waterfall scene in Willow is Burney Falls. A long running Hartford commercial was filmed by Shasta Lake. Mt. Shasta and McCloud were featured in a film and I understand the Alaska scenes in Foxfire were filmed in eastern Shasta County.

  4. Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

    Worth the wait for this to appear on DISH. Thanks.

  5. AJ AJ says:

    I still shake my head every time I hear the name COACHELLA mentioned in regard to the rarified echelons of music performance. When I grew up in the thriving metropolis of Thermal (pop.500), 4 miles to the south, Coachella was considered the “poor relation” next door. And yes, the difference between that site and Arizona 100 miles to the east is hardly discernible.
    But aside from a trip down memory lane .. . I am so happy to learn that we have a worthwhile and viable vehicle here. I barely remember seeing the Judy Garland version but I LOVED the Streisand/Kristofferson production . . .so I am looking forward to this version with with great alacrity. And, another aside, Kristofferson is coming to the Cascade this month. Yea!!

  6. Michael Jewel Haley Michael Jewel Haley says:

    Cooper has said in interviews that the first footage shot for the film was at the 2017 Coachella Music Festival. They literally ran on stage between two other acts and stole five minutes of time in front of a live audience. A clever, and inexpensive, idea.

  7. Steven Towers Steven Towers says:

    I liked it……but as expected, I liked “Crazy Heart” with Jeff Bridges more. The music was damned good. Cooper makes a credible country-rock front man.

    I confess I didn’t get the Gaga character. If I had to boil her character down to one word it would be: Sellout. In my recollection of the previous version of this movie, the Kris Kristofferson character was merely jealous of the Barbra Streisand character’s success eclipsing his own—it seemed kind of petty. In this version, Cooper’s character is genuinely heartbroken that Gaga’s character is squandering her immense talent to be a shitty formulaic pop star.

    (One of the song contributors, Jason Isbell, said that he was allowed to read the script before agreeing to write a song for the movie. He wanted to make sure the male character’s fate wasn’t as lame as the Kristofferson character’s fate. As I recall, the Kristofferson version dies anticlimactically in a car wreck when he drives off in a hissy fit. Anyway, Isbell wrote what I think is the soundtrack’s best song, “Maybe It’s Time.”

    You know how sometimes the end comes and they roll the credits, and then part way through the credits they show an important scene that’s actually the denouement? If you watched “Sharp Objects” on HBO, you know what I mean. Half way through the credits of this one, they should have shown a brief clip of Sam Elliot’s character garroting the Gaga character’s British manager. If you’ve seen the flick, you know you want that to happen.

  8. Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

    My favorite addiction tearjerker movie with great stars and music is The Days Of Wine And Roses.

    • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

      Ah yes, Henry Mancini and Johnny Mercer – what a pair. Days of Wine and Roses and Moon River. When I was in college, I worked one summer at the Seattle World’s Fair. I went to a Johnny Mathis concert, and he was backed up by Henry Mancini’s orchestra. It doesn’t get any better than that.

  9. Avatar Carolyn Dokter says:

    Ahhh, yes, Moon River, Theme from Picnic, I love them!

    • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

      And I just learned that Steve Allen wrote the lyrics to Picnic. Another “theme from” that I love is The Long Hot Summer sung by Jimmie Rogers.