Opinion: How the West Was Lost


Water + Air + Soil + Climate= LIFE

Clearcutting = Production of fiber, but LOSS of clean and plentiful water, air and habitat.

It’s up to you. Which do you value more? Do you want a world where the United States is 5 percent of the population, but uses about a third of the world’s timber, about half of which is made into disposable paper products?

Or do you want a world where there is water you can drink and air you can breathe and diversity of species, a world that is not unbearably hot and barren?

The words “irreparable harm” are easy enough to type and read. It’s quite a different story to live in such a world.

I live in the foothills of Mt. Lassen, where the Sierra and the Cascades overlap. I also live down the road from many thousands of acres of timberland that is owned by Sierra Pacific Industries (SPI), the largest landowner in the state and the second largest in the U.S.

For the past 10 years, SPI has been engaged in the systematic destruction of the Battle Creek watershed here as well as other watersheds from Central California to the Oregon border. SPI practices clearcutting on a huge scale over its land holdings.

Just the facts, ma’am

I have lived in Manton since 1989 and became involved in working against clearcutting – not against logging- when i learned of a Timber Harvest Plan (THP) that was in the Digger Butte area and on Digger Creek, which is one of the borders of my home.

As time passed, I learned how many other THPs were in the area between Manton and Highway 44. There are 13 – with a fourteenth just filed – that cover nearly 20,000 acres.

Each one of these THPs was filed with almost no disclosure of the adjoining THPs and no discussion of the cumulative impacts associated with the sum total of them all.

According to the Dept. of Fish & Game website (www.dfg.ca.gov/habcon/timber) there are not quite 3 million acres of timberland in private ownership in California.

Sierra Pacific Industries owns 1.7 million of those acres, or 58%. (That’s about the size of the state of Delaware, or twice the size of the state of Rhode Island.)

SPI’s ownership is also across 15 counties, so I think it is fair to say that what they do matters and has consequences.

CalFire oversees the THP process, and according to their records, by 2006 SPI had been given approval for clearcutting and other plantation conversion of 45,413 acres in Shasta County alone; the figure is close to a quarter million acres in all of the counties they own land in, and their plans are to cut and convert 1,000,000 acres.

Scientists find that the temperature in clearcut areas increases 5 to 10 degrees while the humidity decreases by 35 percent. Actually, anyone who has ever walked out in a clearcut doesn’t need a scientist to tell them that.

In a time when water supplies are in the decline throughout the West, our watersheds that provide most of the water for the entire state need to be protected. Many studies have been released recently that find forests are more important for protecting the regularity of water flows and the water quality than was previously supposed.

Studies also show that plantations are more fire prone and burn at a higher severity than natural forests. Tree plantations of between 1 to 5-foot tall trees, that have piles of logging debris pushed up against the small replants, will be lucky to survive the next 30 or more years it takes for them to start becoming a forest that can perform all of the complex functions that life as we know it, depends on.

Herbicides and Chemicals

Whenever any chemicals are used commercially, the usage is reported to the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR).

The yearly report released by the DPR is broken down into groups, such as Alfalfa or Grapes or Timberland. In 1989, the usage of chemicals on timberland in Shasta County was 3,699 pounds. By 2006 Timberland usage in Shasta County was 79,596 pounds.

To put that in context: If the 1989 amount was used every year, it would have taken 21 years to use as much as was used in the one year of 2006.

  • At best, no one is certain what effects these chemicals have.
  • At worst, they are linked to much higher cancer rates and birth defects.
  • Many of the chemicals that are used are banned in other countries.

Since I began working against clearcutting, some people have made the remark, “It’s private land, they (SPI) can do what they want.”

I believe in private rights too, but not when it is at the expense of the larger group’s health and well being. When an individual makes the choice to get drunk and drive and endanger others, do we say that it’s their private right?

I encourage anyone who reads this and anyone who ever turns on a faucet with the expectation of water flowing out to look at the aerial view of our area on the Internet at the Google Earth site or go to http://www.thebattlecreekalliance.org/ to see what the land looks like over many, many miles of the state.

Marily Woodhouse is a Sierra Club organizer for the “Stop Clearcutting California” campaign. She lives in Manton.

Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

4 Responses

  1. Avatar Sorca O'Connor says:

    Woodhouse's article brings an extremely important message for all Redding area folks to hear and understand. The beautiful forests that surround the urban area will disappear and the danger of fire closing in on all of us will rise. SPI finds ways, as this article indicates, to make it look like they are cutting a "small patch" of their voluminous holdings, when in fact they are "checker-boarding" the forested land with clearcuts and will turn around in a couple of decades and clearcut the plots that were spared earlier. There will be no more natural forest, the wild animals will flee or die, the water supply will be poisoned, the land will erode, the carbon will fill the air, our piece of the planet will be even a little hotter. Somehow, we citizens who want to prolong earth's liveability for the sake of everyone's children and grandchildren, need to confront this giant landowner with the truth of its destructive actions.

  2. Avatar Randy says:

    Our planet is now in the midst of the "Sixth Great Extinction" and species of plants and animals are disappearing at rates equal to past events such as the ice age but this time it is the irresponsible humans that are fully responsible for this irreversible loss. All native species of plants, insects and animals that could not escape have been eradicated in the clear cuts. The oak trees have been systematically poisoned and eradicated from thousands of acres surrounding the areas that have been clear cut. What are the wildlife to do? What good is tree farm when trying to maintain the native diversity of a forest? Scientists tell us the importance of diversity and in fact the massive species loss now taking place in our own county, our state, nation and entire planet threatens our own existence as well. The open destruction of our environment is complete insanity and we will pay a great price for allowing this to take place when our future generations look back at us..

  3. Avatar mauro oliveira says:

    Clearcutting is equivalent to oil spills. EVERYTHING in a clearcut THP is destroyed or forced out….under the soil is destroyed by the herbicides and the death of the canopy. The wildlife is destroyed by the billions per cut….life giving subterranean webs are poisoned and die.

    Mankind and I mean MANkind better wake up. We are not here to destroy the Earth, we are here to respect and stand in AWE of GOD's CREATION.

    What good are brains if we lose sight that ALL LIFE is Sacred and we should act accordingly?