Judy – An Alcoholic Perspective

Editor's note: If you appreciate posts like this and want ANC to continue publishing similar content, become a paid subscriber for as little as $1.35 a month.


First of all, I think Renee Zellweger is a genius. Second, I think “The Wizard of Oz” is one of the greatest movies of all time. Those are my biases, right up front. So why wouldn’t I want to see “Judy?” Why wouldn’t I ask my wife out on a date? Why, indeed.

It knocked my socks off. Enjoyment of a movie, or any art form, is a personal thing, of course. There needs to be a hook, something to grab hold of you, make it relate to you individually.

On the surface, it would seem that Judy Garland and I have very little in common. I seriously doubt if she ever set any chokers, cut any trees, or dumped garbage cans for a living. I can absolutely guarantee I have never held any audiences spell-bound with my singing. What could a rough ‘ol country boy like myself have in common with a glamorous Hollywood star?

This is where the acting genius of Zellweger comes in. She manages to wear a long-dead singer’s heart on her sleeve. Not so easy. Her eerily-nuanced movement and expressions manage to bring out the insecurity and angst of Garland – and others who suffer from drugs and alcohol. Its an addiction and a vicious cycle; the terrible feeling of inadequacy and guilt that clutches your heart when you have something important to do, but you are too funk to drunktion. The utter and incomprehensible demoralization ripping at your guts when the lovely, lovely alcohol stops working and the speed just makes you feel bad, when you cannot find the zone, and the buzz won’t buzz. When the right dose is impossible to find, and sweet oblivion eludes you, that is when the desperation sets in. The last thing you need is another drink or pill, so you take one just to make things a little better, which never works. Its not a logical process.

For an hour or two, Zellweger gave me back that wonderful feeling of discomfort, desperation and anxiety (gee, thanks, right?) There can be more to the story, like freedom, joy and gratitude, but Garland never found it. She died of the disease, like so many others. Some of them were famous, like Garland and Elvis and Whitney Houston, but many more have suffered and died in obscurity. A couple of friends of mine killed themselves, blew their brains out. I am certain it was the alcohol. Others died in car wrecks, drunk. This demon can be beaten, but its hard, really hard. Judy Garland didn’t make it.

Zellweger sold all that, in the character of Judy Garland. That is her genius.

Of course, no actor can pull this off alone. The critical element is the synergy of the acting, the symbiotic interplay between actors that creates the magic. Good actors feed off each other. A great actress pulls everyone up. When the magic works, we are all transported over the rainbow. I know this movie has gotten mixed reviews, but not from me. I’m all in.

Zellweger is uncanny as Judy, and the rest of the cast, mostly, give great performances. Richard Corderey as Louis B. Mayer is truly (gulp!) imposing. Andy Nyman, as Dan, one of her new-found homosexual friends in London, is endearing. When he stands up in the wonderful ending piece (sorry, trying not to give too much away), he stands on the razor’s edge. This scene could have flopped terribly, but it is brilliant.

The movie shows us the terrible price Garland paid for stardom, the pressure and manipulation of a teenage girl; relentless work schedules and a mother giving drugs to her daughter to keep her thin and drive her to the edge of endurance and the peak of performance.

The contrast is ironic between the ugliness of the movie business and the beauty of the product. Whatever may have been the human follies, foibles and abuses associated with the making of The Wizard of Oz,” it remains one of the great cinematic achievements of all time, and this movie shows us that, along with the darkness. Eighty years later, and fifty years after Garland’s death, we can still celebrate the glory of that achievement. Here is a link to the original “Over the Rainbow.

Ars longa, vita brevis

James Montgomery
James Montgomery calls himself a broken-down logger/garbageman who went back to school, got a law degree, and worked as a nonprofit administrator, before retiring. His interests include hiking, fishing, computers, kayaking, hunting and writing. He is now serving as president of the board of directors of Empire Recovery Center.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

13 Responses

  1. Avatar Bruce Vojtecky says:

    Having drank more than I should at the bar in Douglas City, before it burned down, and driven back to Hayfork without mishap, others didn’t, I feel lucky.
    My favorite drunk movie, which had great performances not to mention great music, is Days Of Wine and Roses.
    Good review Jim I’ll have to see Judy.

    • Avatar James Montgomery says:

      Yeah, I’ve driven that road in various stages of inebriation myself, without incidence. Here’s the secret: when you are so drunk you are seeing double, keep drinking until you see triple, then aim for the middle one. 🙂

  2. Steve Towers Steve Towers says:

    I guess my favorite movie with a drinking theme of sorts would be “Sideways.” I’ll admit that’s in part because the two female characters in the movie really did it for me.

    My favorite joke about having a drinking problem:

    My step-dad told me it was pointless to apply to med school because I was too stupid to be a doctor.

    Eight years later one of us is an unemployed loser with a drinking problem, and the other is pulling down six figures and going to Hawaii this weekend to renew his wedding vows with my mom.

  3. Avatar Sue says:

    On the mountain and in the movie theater – you provide a good read!

  4. Avatar Candace says:

    Wow, what an insightful and beautifully written movie review. I’ve not seen the movie but I will now! Oh, and I also think Zellweger is a phenomenal actor.

  5. Avatar Diana Wallis says:

    Thanks for the great review, Jim. I definitely want to go see this movie now.

  6. R.V. Scheide Jr. R.V. Scheide Jr. says:

    I’ve always had a hard time telling Judy from Liza. It’s like they’re one continuous person.

  7. Thanks, James, for sharing so much of yourself, and for this unexpected departure from your usual work. Nicely done.

  8. Avatar Marjeanne says:

    Well, you convinced me that I need to see the movie, James. Your writing inspired me. And we share some common feelings about the journeys that we have taken, ourselves.

  9. Avatar Alice Bell says:

    Absolutely one of the best acting performances I’ve ever seen. I would be surprised if Zellweger doesn’t win best actress Oscar. The movie focuses mostly on the last few months of Judy Garland’s life. About half way through the movie, I realized how important the flashback scenes were to understanding how she became dependent on drugs, alcohol, and people who didn’t have her best interests in mind. Bring some tissues with you.

  10. Avatar Colleen Adams says:

    Great review, thank you! Just last week in Redding my son sat in the ICU with the husband of a young woman who ended up dying as a direct result of alcoholism. She wasn’t even 40 years old. The experience of addiction to drugs and alcohol is just as wretched now as it was back then, and I am happy to say I haven’t had a drink in 9 years. If I watch this movie I will probably cry the whole time!!!