Americans Could Learn From ‘The Great British Baking Show’

Never am I more aware of how ramped up and divided America is than when I watch the contrast of civility and kindness exhibited on “The Great British Bake Off”, my current favorite means of television escapism and entertainment.

(It can be seen on PBS and Netflix, where it’s known as “The Great British Baking Show” –  because of an American trademark issue with the Pillsbury Bake-off.)

If you’ve missed it (and if you have, that’s a shame) “The Great British Baking Show” is a popular British television series that features elimination rounds between amateur British bakers demonstrating their culinary talents. The contestants are tasked with creating a variety of challenging custards, tarts, puddings, breads, cookies, pies and every kind of sweet and savory delicious food imaginable, mainly things that involve flour and/or sugar. Every 10 weeks it’s a brand new set of bakers.

[s2If !current_user_can(access_s2member_level1)]

Only paid subscribers have access to our site’s lead stories, as well as the Convo Cafe. When you become a recurring subscriber, you will have full access to all lead stories as well as the entire website. Plus, you’ll have the option to receive email notifications of everything we post on

We look forward to you being part of’s online family of paid subscribers. Your support helps us not just survive, but thrive and bring even more quality content to you by top-notch contributors and journalists about topics crucial to you, our region and our world.

Read more about our decision here.

Click here to subscribe!

Already a subscriber? Log in here.


[s2If current_user_can(access_s2member_level1)]


Don’t be fooled into thinking this is a show just for bakers, because scores of non-bakers are fans, too. For good reason. There’s something about watching “The Great British Baking Show” that makes me happy, because although the bakers are under extreme pressure to produce over-the-top difficult “bakes” – the format of the show is fair, compassionate, humorous and thoroughly entertaining. Plus, I learn a lot about baking, which, as a life-long baker, I like.

I realize the show has had its own degree of internal drama, but I prefer to remain willfully ignorant about that, and focus on what I love about it.

What first drew me into show was its people, starting with Paul Hollywood, the hunky handsome famous baker, who I mentioned last year when I wrote about giving up on online dating, because I said I’d found my perfect match. (Turns out he’s not so perfect after all, what with having a rather public roving eye, but it was a nice fantasy while it lasted.)

Paul Hollywood, UK celebrity chef.

But I also adored his co-host, Mary Berry – old enough to be my mother – so talented, so spunky, so smart and so knowledgeable about baking. Likewise, I loved the show’s original presenters, Mel Giedroyc and Sue Perkins, and was so upset when they left the show after a corporate programming shake-up – followed by Mary’s departure — that for a brief time I vowed to no longer watch the new version, with Paul and some new co-hosts (who were perfectly fine). I got over it, and returned to the show. (But it’s still not as good without Mel, Sue and Mary.)

I returned because the program’s enticing, simple format and its earnest, authentic bakers were the real stars of the show. The contestants were a wide mix of regular people, all of whom share a passion for baking. And wow, such an impressive diversity of ethnicity, personality and culture! Gay and straight bakers, white bakers and bakers of color, old and young bakers, single and married bakers, grandparent bakers, mommy and daddy bakers, nerd bakers, white- and blue-collar bakers, shy and outgoing bakers, educated and self-taught bakers, humorous bakers, insecure bakers and pessimistic bakers, often all in the same pool of contestants.

Consequently, “The Great British Baking Show” has spoiled me, and made it so that I can hardly stomach the more cut-throat American cooking shows, where contestants are often mean and rude to their fellow competitors, and are sometimes sore, bitter losers.

American reality television reminds me a lot of American politics, which has effectively pitted Americans against each other. It’s tricked the American masses into believing the destructive messages that claim we’re split between the good guys and the bad guys and it’s every man and woman for themselves and if you don’t agree with me you’re an idiot and just shut up and get out of my sight because I have no use for you or what you think or have to say and we have zero in common.

With American cooking competitions, the prize is money, typically thousands of dollars. With “The Great British Baking Show”, the grand prize is an engraved plate stand, a bouquet of floppy wildflowers, and the satisfaction of being named the winner after 10 weeks of difficult baking challenges.

Other weird, very un-American reality-show things happen during “The Great British Baking Show”. First, the winners are cheered and congratulated by the “losing” contestants. What?!! (And it seems genuine.) Second, when the contestants are waiting for the final verdict, sometimes they are holding hands, or have their arms wrapped around each other.

Why did I assume all these years that the British were undemonstrative? Scratch that.

But the thing that always slays me is when the name is called of the person who’ll be sent home – the loser. The hosts, presenters and other contestants immediately surround the person with hugs and kisses, lingering squeezes, words spoken into necks – as they comfort the departing person. There are tears, not just by the loser, but often by the contestants who openly express sadness that a fellow baker has been sent home. More than once a remaining contestant will say he or she thought they should have been the one sent home. One week, after a contestant who had a fondness for Hawaiian shirts was eliminated, all the contestants showed up the next week wearing Hawaiian shirts in his honor. What the what?

Another thing that strikes me as foreign is that sometimes, when a contestant is having a colossal failure, like a cake is on the verge of falling over, or a baker is on the brink of missing a deadline to plate something, fellow contestants will sometimes jump in to help. I remember one “Chopped” episode where a contestant helped another, but then the show’s host reminded the contestants that they were competitors each vying for $10,000.

On “The Great British Baking Show”, it’s as if even though they’re all there to win, the bakers haven’t lost the ability to still care for and encourage one another. It’s as if the people are more important than the prize, if you can imagine that.

That resonates with me, and I think that mindset resonates with most Americans, too.

That’s why I don’t blame Americans for how they misbehave on American reality cooking shows. Rather, I blame the producers of the shows who egg on the contestants and whip them into a frenzy and encourage them to talk crap about each other and be nasty, because it makes for good television. But does it? Not for me, no more than I like car crashes and high-speed chases in movies (don’t get me started on particular kinds of sex scenes), but for some reason, movie-makers seem to think that’s what we want.

Left to their natural tendencies, most Americans I know would be inclined to help a fellow baker – or neighbor – in trouble, and feel sad at another’s misfortune, despite our differences.

Conversely, I’m reminded of our highly polarized American political system, where our country, families and friendships are increasingly divided. Liberal and conservative labels are conveniently lazy, and allow us instant prejudice to justify dismissing someone before we even get a chance to truly know them.

Don’t most of us want the same simple things from life? Yes, we do. Clean air, decent housing, equal opportunities in education, health care and employment, to name a few. But as long as we’re fighting, we can never come together to find common ground to solve our country’s problems. As long as we’re fighting, we’re not listening and considering that perhaps, we have more in common than we know. As long as we’re fighting, we’ll never know.

Back to “The Great British Baking Show”, about which I am not ashamed to admit that I have wept at the finale of almost every episode. I think what touches me most is how all the families and friends have gathered on the lawn outside that huge white tent, all the former contestants, winners and losers; all eating cake. All united.

Here in the so-called United States, we are embroiled in one of the most contentious times in American history. Here we have gay and straight Americans, white Americans and Americans of color; old and young Americans, single and married Americans, grandparent Americans, mommy and daddy Americans, nerd Americans, white- and blue-collar Americans, shy and outgoing Americans, educated and self-taught Americans, humorous Americans, insecure Americans and pessimistic Americans, often in the same city.

Despite our differences, we  have so much in common. But there’s so much at stake if we can’t acknowledge how we’re alike; reject the messages of hate and division, and unite for the good of us all.

Yes, we have a long way to go. Maybe we could start by baking a cake.


Doni Chamberlain
Independent online journalist Doni Chamberlain founded what’s now known as in 2007 with her son, Joe Domke. Chamberlain is an award-winning newspaper opinion columnist, feature and food writer recognized by the Associated Press, the California Newspaper Publishers Association and E.W. Scripps. She lives in Redding, California.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

24 Responses

  1. Barbara Rice Barbara Rice says:

    Yes. That is what is so appealing about TGBBS – how kind all the contestants are to each other. It’s sort of like Mr. Rogers for cooks.

  2. Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

    I guess I should have watched more than one episode of TGBBS. That one show really puzzled me. The contestants were baking something that required a long rise time so between the prep and rise, there wasn’t enough time for it to bake; yet they were judged on the final underbaked product. Made no sense to me.

    I’ve often thought that if I were on a panel where each person had a nameplate which included such descriptions as African American and Mexican American, I would insist that my nameplate state English, French, Norse, a touch of Armenian and Basque, some Italian and Spanish American. Since most American blacks have never been to Africa and many of Mexican descent are third generation Americans, why the labels? End of rant.

  3. Avatar Debbie Davis says:

    Love your message of peace. It begins in our own hearts. I think eating cake together is an excellent idea!

  4. Avatar Cynthia Stuart says:

    I’m pretty sure I didn’t get the dessert baking gene since I can only produce pies that are clearly homemade. Nevertheless, binge watching the GBBS has inspired a deep desire in me to make a layered sponge that doesn’t tilt or slide. What I love about the show is exactly what you wrote—the people, the kindness, the pride in achievement versus financial reward. It’s theatre at its feel-good best. Cheers!

    • It IS an inspirational program, and it often sends me running to the kitchen to try something. I should have mentioned my education in British cooking terms, like referring to items as “bakes”, and cakes as sponges, and all kinds of descriptive words and phrases we don’t use here. (Soggy bottoms, etc.) And many of their foods and techniques are foreign to me, too, like hot-water crusts, and the heavy use of of passion fruit in their desserts, and baked puddings (not the Jell-O kind), and even things that we don’t see much here, like trifles.

      It kind of makes me want to be British.

      Sometimes I wonder if many of us will start incorporating the GBBS words and pronunciations into our culture.

      • Avatar Cynthia Stuart says:

        I created a “translation” list of terms from UK to US. I would never have figured out that “hundreds and thousands” are what we call “sprinkles.”

      • Avatar Richard Christoph says:

        “It kind of makes me want to be British.”

        Indeed. The first time Terri and I visited the U.K. we concluded that perhaps the colonists had made a horrible mistake.

  5. Avatar Carolyn Dokter says:

    I so like that show, never miss it. I wholeheartedly agree with your article.

  6. Hal Johnson Hal Johnson says:

    Before Starbucks came to town and the business folded, I would now-and-then stop by a coffee place on Park Marina. If memory serves, it was called “Hill of Beans.” Three different times, I witnessed debates between the staunchly liberal owner and one of his regulars, a resolute conservative.

    They were both passionate in their beliefs, and sometimes, things would get heated, but before the regular would leave, they would talk about small stuff that they agreed on. When the regular left for the day, they parted as friends.

    Sometimes, I wonder what happened to that America.

    • Avatar Beverly Stafford says:

      Your comment, “Sometimes, I wonder what happened to that America” resonates, Hal. I’m aghast at the name-calling by POTUS and politicians and newscasters. What happened to civility?

  7. Avatar Gayle Rice says:

    I’m not much of a baker and I rarely watch television, but I will watch this show. The creativity, kindness, and support of contestants and judges is amazing. I also like that there is not an annoying, snarky, wanna be comedian as a host. I don’t miss the fake laughter of an audience either.

  8. Avatar Matthew Grigsby says:

    I’m one of those non-baking, non-cooking fans of the show. When I was suffering through The Year That Was in 2017, I discovered TGBBS and it became a source of great comfort. Seriously.

    • Avatar Matthew Grigsby says:

      (I accidentally cut myself off there). When I needed an escape, a smile, some happy tears or just a glimpse into a world that wasn’t steaming hot garbage, I always turned to TGBBS and it always worked. I got fully invested in the contestants and their challenges and their foibles and their victories. I also became an armchair expert on what they should or shouldn’t do. “Let your dough prove longer! You don’t have the rise you need!” or “You’re making a reckless choice using such a wet filling on that bake! You’ll get a soggy bottom!”

      I also love that the criticism can be devastating but ALWAYS fair and never cruel. If the judges don’t like something, they say exactly why and take no pleasure from the dashed dreams of the contestants. Seeing the contestants scramble to help each other warms my cold, black heart every time. The only other competition show I’ve ever seen that happen is on “Face Off” on the SyFy channel, which is about special effects makeup. We need more of this kind of support in the world.

      • Avatar Matthew Grigsby says:

        PS. I usually end up following some of the GBBS contestants on Twitter and they are just as lovely as they are on the show.

  9. Deb Segelitz Deb Segelitz says:

    Sem isn’t a fan of cooking/baking shows, so I haven’t had a chance to watch GBBO (as they call it here). But wholly in your (and Matt’s) honor, I caught the first two episodes of the 2017 show while Sem was at dialysis (my “guilty pleasure TV” opportunity if I have the time), and it was as delightful as you said. Love the parallels to the lessons it can teach us, too!

  10. Joanne Snyder Joanne Snyder says:

    I really loved this article! I have to admit that I love to listen to the San Francisco Giants games because of the announcers….who share a warm give and take while doing a huge job. It’s a comfort. I used to listen to KQMS Billy and Patrick in the morning because they share a cooperative and kind relationship that carries through in their voices even when they disagree about something. I know my comments have nothing to do with baking, but insults, name calling and public embarrassment are behaviors I can’t stand. I think I would enjoy this show. I’m reminded that many countries have had a longer time for workable harmonious living behaviors and manners to develop.

  11. Avatar Karen Hafenstein says:

    If I were a great writer, I would have written exactly what you wrote. (See why I’m not?) I no longer watch American cooking shows because of the braggadocio, cut-throat-ness, etc. I will remain a big fan of The Great British Baking Show and hope some of its emotional qualities rub off on Americans who need it!

  12. Avatar Janine Hall says:

    I love this show. I really love how kind the bakers are to each other. Never hear words like you do on the Master Chef, unnecessary words. I love cooking and love to learn more things. I don’t need to learn more curse words, I think I know them all.