Where Has All Our Money Gone?

Editor's note: If you appreciate being able to read posts like this one, and want to ensure ANC's ability to provide more content like this, please click here to demonstrate your support and become a paid subscriber.

Recently I was encouraged to take a look at an important book that has some answers for the future of our society and democracy. The book is Capital in the Twenty-First Century by Thomas Piketty, a political economist. It seemed to shock the pundits of the talk shows, but to me it explained the obvious, backed up with three centuries of data from 20 countries.

Capital is wealth. Capitalism is the accumulation of wealth. Corporate capitalism is the system that has created the 1% and the 99% classes. I know this is a simplification, but it helps me to keep things in perspective.

How unequal are we? Here’s some info adding to what we already intrinsically know:

  • We’re not recovering from the “Great Recession.” The lowest 93% of households lost 4% of their worth, but the top 7% grew by 28%. Worldwide the wealthiest 1% got 95% of the growth from the post-financial crisis since 2009.
  • Huge amounts of capital are often amassed by off shore corporations not paying their fair share of taxes, shifting the tax burden to you and me.
  • We can’t get ahead. The cost of living is higher than our incomes so we are going deeper in debt, even though many families have three jobs.
  • Minimum wages are becoming more and more minimum. Did you know the minimum wage (adjusted for inflation) in the 1970s is the same as the proposed hike to $10.10?
  • The great obscene gap between the wealthy 1% and the rest of us is now worldwide and has been growing worse since 2009. The wealthy 1% controls about 50% of the world’s wealth, and the 85 wealthiest families control the same portion of wealth as 3.5 billion of the poorest people. Did you know that 49% of members of Congress are millionaires compared to 1% of the general population? This just in – the top 3% now controls 54% of our country’s wealth.
  • The wealthy are buying our politicians. Disparity of wealth makes democracy undemocratic, especially after the Supreme Court ruling allowing unlimited campaign spending by corporations.

Piketty’s research demonstrates that a so-called self-regulating market-based system has a built-in bias favoring those with capital assets over those living on wages alone.  His conclusion is that, without fundamental system change or politically prescribed adjustments, the distribution of wealth will tend inevitably to concentrate in fewer and fewer hands with all the social and economic problems that such disparity causes.

The result has been a dangerous unequal distribution of wealth. The main reason for inequality is that the returns on capital exceed economic growth involving production and wages. When inequalities reach the extreme levels that they are at now, it threatens our democracy and may result in frequent civil unrest movements.

Political action by our government corrected most of the dangerous inequalities after the last great Wall Street collapse and the Great Depression. Roosevelt’s New Deal and WWII got us out of the last economic jam, but it took years of hardship recovery for us to get to the golden years of economic life, 1945-1975. What will it take to get the economic ball rolling uphill again?

What’s in store for US/us?

  1. Another collapse, stock markets or the tech industry, like the housing bubble but probably much worse?
  2. More and bigger revolts and riots involving the unemployed and striking minimum wagers?
  3. Replacing corporate capitalism by changing into a steady-state economy or changing to a “social capitalism” system as in Scandinavian countries?
  4. Tax on wealth as suggested by Thomas Piketty. Tax salaries over $500,000 at 80% worldwide and tax wealth at 15% worldwide. Corporate capitalism is global, so capitalist countries must cooperate, or the wealth will just flow to the place of lower taxes.
  5. In the US, we could encourage employee-owned businesses, social enterprises where money earned is used for social purposes, traditional co-ops, community development corporations, land trusts, government-owned and operated businesses, transformation of the “too big to fail” banks into public utilities and replacing Wall Street.

Both our political and economic systems are highly dysfunctional. And, here’s another important issue: eminent scientists think that revamping our economic system is integral to dealing with climate change. I fear that any action to improve climate will be too late to save our grandkids from hardships. This fear is not mine alone but shared by many.

Try reading: Agenda for a New Economy, 2nd Edition, by David C. Korton

Capital in the Twenty-First Century by Thomas Piketty

What Then Must We Do? By Gar Alperovitz

Who Stole the American Dream by Hendrick Smith

Who Rules America by William Domholf, http://whorulesamerica.net/power/wealth.html

Wayne Kessler is the former owner of Shambani Organics, former Peace Corps volunteer, and founding member of Growing Local.

Wayne Kessler
Following his grandfather's advice, "Grow food. People always need food," has led Wayne to a lifetime of cultivating and processing food. He spends much of his time encouraging people to become more food independent by growing their own.
Comment Policy: We welcome your comments, with some caveats: Please keep your comments positive and civilized. If your comment is critical, please make it constructive. If your comment is rude, we will delete it. If you are constantly negative or a general pest, troll, or hater, we will ban you from the site forever. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Comments are disabled on articles older than 90 days. Thank you. Carry on.

8 Responses

  1. Thank you Wayne well said.

  2. Avatar CouldBeTrouble says:

    The people have the power to change all this and in fact taught corporate America and Corporate World, for that matter, how much power they really have, but they have forgotten or are too addicted to us it. The power of the purse that Congress fails to use against the biggest and most wasteful spending president of all time. Conservatism, common sense, practicality and voting wisely are all but a thing of the past and you will not see Common Core classes teaching these subjects. When people finally realize how good we had it without all the “glitz” and convenience it will be too late to turn back. Welcome to Agenda 21. Your right on schedule.

  3. Avatar pmarshall says:

    I have to agree with all of that. Common sense went away long ago.

  4. Avatar cheyenne says:

    When I read about the plight of the lower wage earners protesting for higher wages I remember Cesar Chavez and his boycotts of wine stores to get better treatment for farmworkers. It was successful.
    Now I read about people saying those rich evil corporations like Burger King(inversion move planned), and Wal Mart should pay more. those same people calling for higher wages shouldn’t patronize those businesses but they still do. The only way those corporations are going to pay more is if it affects their bottom line. So don’t patronize them.
    Walgreens was going to do an inversion but protests from their customers stopped them. The little people can change things. Don’t wait for politicians because they only serve the rich.

    • Avatar Christian says:

      YES! Well said! The US Supreme Court has ruled that MONEY has the SAME individual constitutional rights as you and I do as US citizens.

      SO, let’s empower our money and our constitution buy letting the mega corporatocray and their puppets in government know we do not like what they are doing to our country and to the best we can stop giving them our money.

      I say go as green, go as local and as sustainable as we can and…Viva La Huelga!

  5. Avatar Grammy says:

    I think the people running for office, start with a good heart, then they sell out. It takes a lot of money to get elected (to me this is irony in the fullest that to be elected to an office that earns $120,000 cost millions to get elected). The money that the 99% contribute will never get that person elected. It takes the millions that corporations and the wealthy with their own agenda (and it is not thinking of the 99%)
    It doesn’t help that the Federal Reserve is not owned by the American people so decisions to our future is not in our hands.

  6. Avatar Pamela says:

    Right on Wayne!

  7. I know we have voting rights in this country, but think about it: how much do we really get to vote for compared to how much government officials (Congressmen, Senators, state reps, etc) get to vote for? I feel sometimes like the issues ~ and people ~ we get to vote on are paltry, barely scratching the surface of what is controlled by the branches of government. How much power do we really have?